I loosened my tie. “So, where am I sleeping?”
The blush came fast.
Play
00:00
00:00
01:31
Mute
Play
Not a polite hint of color. Not a shy little glow. A full, unmistakable blush that started in her cheeks and traveled down her neck until she looked away and pretended to study a basket of folded blankets by the wall.
And suddenly, I knew.
She had thought about it before I asked.
Maybe in the truck. Maybe before she ever walked up to me outside that wedding barn holding my jacket like a decision.
“There’s a guest room,” she said.
“Okay.”
She bit her lip. “Technically.”
I waited.
“It has boxes in it.”
“How many boxes?”
“A confident amount.”
I took one slow breath. “Emily.”
She looked back at me then, and the humor was there, but so was something more unsteady.
“I didn’t ask you because I needed a driver,” she said.
The hallway went quiet around us.
Her hand was on the banister. Mine was on my loosened tie. We stood three feet apart in her childhood home, too old to pretend we didn’t know what that sentence meant and too careful to step toward it without being invited.
Then she came down one stair, making herself almost eye level with me.
My jacket slipped off one shoulder.
I reached out to fix it before I thought better of it, and my fingers brushed the bare skin near her collarbone.
Neither of us moved.
Emily looked at my hand, then at my mouth, then back into my eyes.
“Ben,” she whispered, “if you’re going to be careful with me tonight…”
I waited, because whatever came next had to be hers.
She swallowed.
“Don’t be so careful that I think you don’t want to stay.”
For a second, I forgot how to breathe.
Not because restraint left me, but because Emily Carter had just placed her hand on a door I had been standing outside for months and asked very softly if I was ever going to knock.
I let my fingers rest at her shoulder. Warm skin under my knuckles. My jacket sliding another inch down her arm.
“I want to stay,” I said.
Her breath hitched.
No joke. No escape hatch. No neighborly version of it.
Just the truth, standing between us in the dark hallway.
“Good,” she whispered.
Then she rose onto her toes and kissed me.
It wasn’t the kind of kiss that knocks furniture over. It wasn’t desperate or careless. It was almost shy at first, her mouth brushing mine like she was asking one more question.
I answered by leaning in.
One hand at her waist. The other at the back of her neck.
She made the smallest sound, and that almost undid me.
Emily Carter, who could tease me into silence in an elevator and make a room full of strangers pose for a photo like they trusted her, softened against me in the hallway of her parents’ house as if she had been tired for a long time and had finally found somewhere to rest.
I kissed her again, slower.
She tasted like champagne and wedding cake frosting.
When her hands came up to my chest, they didn’t push me away.
They curled into my shirt.
Then the old house creaked above us.
We broke apart like teenagers caught after curfew.
Emily stared at the ceiling.
I stared at Emily.
“That was the radiator,” she whispered.
“It’s June.”
“Then it was a judgmental ghost.”
I laughed under my breath and dropped my forehead briefly to hers. “Does the ghost have opinions about overnight guests?”
“Definitely. But she’s from 1998, so she’s mostly upset about my eyebrows.”
That made me laugh harder, and the tension loosened without disappearing. It changed shape. Became something we could hold without being burned by it.
Emily stepped back, smoothing a hand over her dress even though nothing about her looked smooth anymore. Her lips were pink. My jacket hung from one elbow. Her eyes kept darting to mine and away again, as if she couldn’t decide whether to be brave or embarrassed.
I decided to save us both.
“Show me the confident boxes.”
She blinked. “What?”
“The guest room. Let’s assess the situation.”
Her smile came back crooked and relieved. “Very practical.”
“I contain multitudes.”
“Do any of your multitudes contain a toothbrush?”
“No.”
“Then your multitudes have gaps.”
Part 2
The guest room was worse than advertised.
Boxes did not simply occupy it. They had colonized it.
Cardboard towers labeled Christmas, taxes 2011, Mom’s fabric, and do not throw out surrounded a narrow bed like a military defense system. A ceramic goose wearing a bonnet sat on the pillow, guarding the territory with dead porcelain eyes.
I folded my arms. “That goose has seen things.”
Emily stood beside me, biting her lip. “In my defense, I haven’t lived here in years.”
“You said confident. This is imperial.”
“I can move some.”
“At one in the morning?”
She looked at the bed, then me, then the goose.
“I guess there’s the couch.”
We both knew there was a couch. We had passed it downstairs. Floral. Short. Hostile to spines.
“I’ll take it,” I said.
She frowned immediately. “Ben, you’re six-one.”
“Six foot.”
“You told me six-one.”
“I was wearing boots.”
She gave me a look. “You are not sleeping folded in half on my mother’s rose-print couch because you’re trying to prove you’re noble.”
“I’m not proving anything.”
“You kind of are.”
I looked at her then. Really looked.
The playfulness was still there, but under it was worry. Not that I’d do something wrong. Almost the opposite. She was afraid I would back away so far that she’d feel foolish for reaching.
So I said, “I can sleep on the floor in your room.”
Her eyes widened.
“With blankets,” I added. “A pillow. A legally respectable distance.”
Her mouth trembled with suppressed laughter. “Legally respectable?”
“I don’t know Ohio law regarding childhood bedrooms.”
“My room has glow-in-the-dark stars on the ceiling.”
“Then I’ll be supervised by the cosmos.”
She laughed, and the sound eased something in my chest.
Her room was at the end of the hall. It was smaller than I expected and more Emily than I was ready for. Pale blue walls. Shelves of old paperbacks. A corkboard with faded photo strips, concert tickets, and a Polaroid of teenage Emily making a face at the camera. A camera manual sat open on the desk like she had left yesterday instead of years ago.
Above the bed, sure enough, tiny plastic stars dotted the ceiling.
Emily stood in the doorway while I took it in.
“This is embarrassing,” she said.
“No, it isn’t.”
“You’re looking at my high school self.”
“She had good taste in books.”
“She had terrible taste in boys.”
I turned. “Had?”
The word left my mouth before I could soften it.
Emily’s cheeks colored again, but this time she didn’t look away.
“She’s improving,” she said.
A silence opened between us, warm and dangerous.
I set my tie over the back of her desk chair. “Emily.”
“Ben.”
“I’m going to make up the floor before I kiss you again.”
Her eyebrows lifted. “That sounds like a threat.”
“It’s a survival strategy.”
“Yours or mine?”
I stepped closer, just one step, enough that she had to tilt her chin up.
“Both, probably.”
Her gaze dropped to my mouth. “That’s annoying.”
“I’ve been called worse.”
“I don’t want worse.”
The words were quiet, but they changed the room.
She sat on the edge of the bed, suddenly looking younger without seeming childish. Just unguarded. She rubbed her thumb along the hem of my jacket, which she still hadn’t given back.
“My last boyfriend,” she said, “was very good at wanting me when it was easy.”
I stayed where I was. Close, but not crowding her.
“Parties,” she continued. “Weekends. Cute photos. The version of me that made him look good. But if I needed something inconvenient, he made me feel like I had asked too much.”
I sat slowly on the old desk chair.
“That why you almost didn’t ask me tonight?”
She nodded.
“I was standing outside with your jacket, and I thought, he’ll say yes because he’s kind. Then I thought, what if he says yes because he wants me to think he’s kind? Then I thought, what if he says no and I’ve ruined elevators forever?”
I smiled softly. “Elevators were already pretty charged.”
Her laugh came watery at the edges.
I moved closer and crouched in front of her, not touching until she looked at me.
“I didn’t say yes to be kind,” I said. “Kind would have been calling you a ride share and waiting until it came.”
Her eyes held mine.
“I said yes because when you asked me, part of me was relieved I finally had a reason not to leave you at the end of the night.”
She went still.
Then she reached for me.
Not a dramatic grab. Just her hand sliding along my jaw, thumb brushing near the corner of my mouth.
“I want you to kiss me again,” she said.
So I did.
This kiss was deeper. Less question, more answer. Her knees parted enough for me to fit closer, and I kept one hand braced on the mattress, the other at her waist, feeling her inhale against me.
When we separated, she rested her forehead against mine.
“Still sleeping on the floor,” she murmured.
I closed my eyes. “I am trying to be a gentleman.”
“I’m not asking you not to be.” Her fingers traced my collar. “I’m asking you not to use it as a hiding place.”
That hit somewhere tender.
I looked at her, and she must have seen the truth before I said it.
“I’m rusty,” I admitted. “At wanting something and trusting it won’t turn into a mistake.”
Her expression softened.
“Me too,” she said.
For a while, we just stayed there. Me kneeling in a room full of old books and moonlight, her hands resting on my shoulders, both of us breathing through the strange relief of being honest.
Then she stood, opened her closet, and pulled down an old quilt.
“For the floor,” she said.
I took it from her. Our fingers brushed.
She smiled.
“But if the judgmental ghost gets too loud,” she added, “you can come sit on the bed until she calms down.”
I looked at the glow-in-the-dark stars above us.
“Emily?”
“Yeah?”
“I don’t think the ghost is the problem.”
Her blush answered before she did.
I slept on the floor.
Technically, the quilt was under me, a crocheted blanket was over me, and a pillow shaped like a seashell supported half my neck and none of my dignity.
Around three in the morning, I woke to find Emily’s hand hanging off the edge of the mattress, fingers loose and open in the dark.
I stared at it for a full minute like it was a complicated wiring diagram.
Then she whispered, “Ben?”
“Yeah?”
“Are you awake?”
“No. This is my ghost voice.”
A soft laugh slipped out of her.
The stars on her ceiling glowed faintly above us, a green little universe holding its breath.
“I can’t sleep,” she said.
“Me neither.”
A pause.
Then her fingers moved just slightly.
I reached up and took her hand.
That was all.
My back on the floor. Her body tucked above me under the blankets. Our hands linked in the narrow space between.
It should have felt awkward.
It did feel awkward.
It also felt like a promise neither of us was ready to say in daylight.
Her thumb brushed mine.
“Is this okay?” she asked.
I smiled into the dark. “I was about to ask you that.”
“It’s okay.”
“Then yes.”
For a while, we listened to the old house settle. Pipes ticked. A car passed somewhere outside. Emily’s breathing slowly evened out, but she didn’t let go.
Neither did I.
When I woke again, pale morning light was pouring across the floor, and her mother was yelling downstairs.
Not a danger yell.
A very specific Midwestern mother in a kitchen yell.
“Emily Anne Carter!”
Emily shot upright so fast the blanket slid to her waist.
I sat up too, instantly regretting every decision my spine had made overnight.
From downstairs came, “There is a man’s shoe by my umbrella stand.”
Emily’s eyes went wide.
I looked toward the door. “Only one?”
She slapped a hand over her mouth.
“Do not laugh,” she whispered.
“I’m not.”
“You are shaking.”
“I’m in pain.”
“You’re smiling in pain.”
The bedroom door was still closed, thank God, but footsteps were already coming up the stairs.
Emily scrambled out of bed, hair wild, wearing a T-shirt and pajama shorts she had changed into the night before after politely making me turn around like we were at summer camp.
My dress shirt was wrinkled beyond repair. My tie was somewhere on her desk. One of my socks had disappeared into a childhood memory.
“Mom,” Emily called, voice cracking. “Don’t come in.”
The footsteps stopped.
Silence.
Then, much more carefully, her mother asked, “Is everyone dressed?”
Emily closed her eyes.
I looked at Emily.
Emily looked at me.
Then she opened the door three inches.
“Hi, Mom.”
I couldn’t see Mrs. Carter’s whole face, but I could hear her reading the entire situation through that gap. The blush. The bedhead. Me sitting on the floor with a seashell pillow in my lap like evidence.
“Oh,” her mother said.
“Nothing happened,” Emily blurted.
I stood because sitting seemed worse and immediately hit my shoulder on a low shelf.
A ceramic horse wobbled.
I caught it.
Mrs. Carter leaned slightly into view. She was petite, silver-haired, wearing a robe with blue hydrangeas and an expression that was trying very hard to be modern.
“Good morning,” I said.
“Good morning,” she replied.
Emily looked like she wanted the stars to fall from the ceiling and bury us both.
Her mother’s gaze flicked to the floor bedding, then to Emily, then to me.
“Well,” she said. “There’s coffee.”
Then she walked away.
Emily shut the door and pressed her forehead against it.
I waited three seconds.
Then I said, “I think she likes me.”
Emily turned around slowly. “You caught the horse. That bought you at least Christmas.”
Breakfast was both worse and better than I expected.
Mr. Carter was out golfing, which Emily whispered was either mercy or cowardice. Her mother, Linda, made eggs and toast while asking me questions with terrifying cheerfulness.
“So, Ben,” she said, pouring coffee. “Emily says you live in her building.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“And you drove her here last night?”
“Yes.”
“At one in the morning?”
“Yes.”
“Two hours?”
“Yes.”
Linda smiled into her coffee. “That’s a long drive for a neighbor.”
Emily choked on orange juice.
I looked across the table at her. She was flushed again, but this time there was laughter in her eyes too. Something brave. Something that didn’t want me to rescue her from the question.
So I didn’t.
“It is,” I said.
Linda’s eyebrows lifted.
Emily went still.
I set down my coffee. “But I was glad she asked.”
Emily’s gaze softened so suddenly I nearly forgot her mother was three feet away holding a spatula like courtroom evidence.
Linda looked between us, and her smile changed.
Less teasing. More tender.
“Well,” she said, turning back to the stove. “Then have another piece of toast.”
After breakfast, Emily took me to the lake.
We walked three blocks through quiet streets, her in jeans and a faded sweatshirt, me in last night’s suit pants and a borrowed T-shirt from her father that said Lake Erie Walleye Classic.
She laughed every time she looked at it.
“You know,” I said, “some women appreciate a man in formal fishing attire.”
“I’m trying to be respectful. It’s just very powerful.”
“You’re intimidated.”
“I’m overwhelmed.”
The lake was gray-blue and endless under the morning sun. A breeze came off the water, cool enough that she tucked her hands into her sleeves.
We sat on a bench facing the waves, shoulders almost touching.
Then not almost.
She leaned into me.
I put my arm around her slowly enough that she could move away.
She didn’t.
Instead, she rested her head against my shoulder.
For a while, we watched the water without talking.
The quiet between us felt different there than it had in the truck. Less charged with what might happen. More full of what already had.
“I thought I’d feel embarrassed this morning,” she said.
“Do you?”
“A little.” She tilted her face up to me. “But mostly I feel calm.”
The wind had pinked her cheeks. Her hair kept blowing into her mouth, and she kept failing to catch it.
I brushed it back for her.
Her eyes closed briefly at the touch.
“I don’t want to make this smaller than it is,” I said.
She opened her eyes.
“I also don’t want to rush you because we kissed in a hallway and held hands like scandalous teenagers under glow-in-the-dark stars.”
Her smile curved. “That was pretty scandalous.”
“The seashell pillow will never recover.”
She laughed, then reached for my hand on the bench.
“I don’t want to make it small either,” she said. “I’m scared if we call it something, we’ll break it.”
“Maybe not calling it something is how we break it.”
That made her look at me.
I swallowed.
“I’m not asking for a five-year plan on a bench in your hometown,” I said. “But I am asking if I can take you out when we get back. A real date. Not a wedding escape. Not a neighbor favor. A date where I pick the restaurant and you judge my playlist with your whole heart.”
Her fingers tightened around mine.
“You’re asking me on a date while wearing a fish shirt.”
“I wanted you to know the worst early.”
She looked at the water, trying not to smile too fast and failing.
“Yes,” she said.
My chest loosened. “Yes?”
“Yes, Ben. Take me on a real date.”
She leaned closer, her mouth near mine.
“But I pick dessert.”
“That seems fair.”
“And I get one veto on the playlist.”
“One per hour.”
“Emily.”
She kissed me before I could object.
It was brief, warm, and sure. No hallway hesitation this time. No question hiding under it.
Just her hand on my chest and her lips on mine, choosing me in the morning light.
When she pulled back, her smile was shy enough to undo me.
“There,” she said. “Now it’s officially not small.”
I looked at her, at the lake behind her, at the future suddenly taking the shape of dinner reservations and elevator rides that would never be casual again.
“No,” I said, and kissed her knuckles. “It really isn’t.”
Part 3
The drive back to Columbus felt shorter, which made no sense until I realized we were both pretending not to be disappointed it would end.
Emily sat beside me wearing my jacket again. She had returned it twice. I had handed it back twice. By the third time, she stopped pretending.
“This is theft,” I said.
“This is custody.”
“Of my jacket.”
“Our jacket.”
I glanced over. “Our?”
She looked out the window, but I saw her smile reflected in the glass. “Don’t make it weird.”
“I drove you two hours to your childhood bedroom, slept under plastic stars, met your mother, and got kissed by Lake Erie. I think weird has been established.”
She laughed, then reached across the console and laced her fingers with mine.
That was new.
Not the touching. We had done that.
But this was daylight. Highway. No wedding champagne. No sleeping house around us.
Just her choosing my hand because she wanted it.
I lifted her knuckles to my mouth.
She went quiet.
When I glanced over, her eyes were on me with an expression that made the road feel suddenly irrelevant.
“What?” I asked.
“Nothing.”
“Emily.”
She looked down at our hands. “I’m just trying to remember this exact version of you.”
“What version?”
“The one who kisses my hand like it’s easy.”
“It is easy.”
Her thumb moved over mine. “For you, maybe.”
The tenderness in her voice stole every clever answer I had.
We stopped halfway home at a diner with red vinyl booths and a pie case that looked more trustworthy than most banks.
“It isn’t the official date,” Emily said before we even sat down.
“Because of my fish shirt?”
“Partly. Also because I’m wearing yesterday’s mascara and your stolen jacket.”
“I was going to say you look beautiful.”
She froze with the menu half open.
I froze too, because honesty still had the power to surprise both of us.
Then she lowered the menu slowly.
“You can’t just say things like that in a diner.”
“Why not?”
“Because there are witnesses and pie.”
“The pie can handle it.”
Her cheeks warmed, but she didn’t hide behind the menu this time.
“Say it again,” she said.
I leaned forward.
“You look beautiful.”
Her smile came softer than laughter.
“Okay,” she whispered. “Okay. Maybe this can be a pre-date. A rehearsal date with pie and witnesses.”
She nudged my shoe under the table.
“You’re doing well so far.”
I should have been relaxed.
Instead, I was happy in a way that made me nervous. Like if I moved too quickly, I would scare it off. Like joy was a bird that had landed on the table between us, pecking at sugar packets.
After lunch, as we neared our building, Emily’s phone buzzed.
She looked at it.
Her face changed.
Not dramatically. Just enough.
I pulled into the parking lot and killed the engine.
“Everything okay?”
See more on the next page
Advertisement
To see the full cooking instructions, go to the next page or click the Open button (>) and don't forget to SHARE it with your friends on Facebook.
